Multiple sclerosis, ALS and Guillain-Barré syndrome
Stem
A 66-year-old man, 82 kg, with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis diagnosed two years ago, fell and fractured his left femoral neck and is booked for a hemiarthroplasty. Weakness began in his legs; he now has mild dysarthria and coughs when drinking thin liquids. Forced vital capacity is 52% of predicted, and he uses BiPAP at night. He takes riluzole. Blood pressure 138/80, SpO2 94% on room air.
Question
What is your anesthetic plan?
Ideal answer
HeadlineSpinal anesthesia with light sedation is my first choice; succinylcholine never, and I plan his breathing after surgery before I start.
- Settle goals first. Would he accept intubation or a tracheostomy if he cannot be extubated? Respiratory failure is how ALS kills.1
- Spinal plus a fascia iliaca block, BiPAP on hand, because it avoids relaxants and airway instrumentation; the fear of neuraxial worsening is contested, and I discuss it.1
- If general: rapid sequence with rocuronium, no succinylcholine. Upregulated receptors cause hyperkalemia, and bulbar weakness means aspiration risk.1
- Reduced nondepolarizer dose, quantitative monitoring, sugammadex, because these patients are sensitive and residual block will not be tolerated.1,2
- Extubate fully awake onto BiPAP, monitored bed, with minimal opioid.
Watch for: rising CO2 with a normal saturation, a weak cough, pooled secretions.
Breaking down the answer
- Succinylcholine across all three — denervation spreads acetylcholine receptors beyond the junction, so potassium surges; it is contraindicated in Guillain-Barré and best avoided in neuromuscular disease generally.3,2 Changes if: never; rocuronium with sugammadex covers rapid sequence.
- Neuraxial and MS relapse — a systematic review of 37 reports and 231 patients found no clear cause and effect;4 a 2025 review of 1,315 parturients found no rise in postpartum relapse, which tracks disease activity instead.5
- What does trigger MS relapse — fever, infection and stress, so I keep him normothermic and treat infection.5
- Guillain-Barré ventilation thresholds — vital capacity under 20 mL/kg, maximal inspiratory pressure weaker than 30 cmH2O, expiratory under 40, or a 30% fall.3
- Who will need the ventilator — in 222 Guillain-Barré patients, 17% were ventilated; bulbar dysfunction (OR 18.7) and dysautonomia (OR 11.6) were the strongest predictors.6
- Evidence base — respiratory complications in neuromuscular series run 0–54%; sugammadex looks safe but data are thin.2
Follow-up question
The next morning you are called to the ward for a 38-year-old woman admitted three days ago with ascending weakness from Guillain-Barré syndrome. Her vital capacity is now 15 mL/kg, she cannot count to 15 in one breath, and her blood pressure has swung from 190/100 to 85/45 in an hour with heart rate 50 to 130. What do you do?
Follow-up answer
HeadlineImpending respiratory failure with dysautonomia; I move her to the ICU and intubate now, before she tires.
Her vital capacity is below the 20 mL/kg threshold,3 and dysautonomia predicts ventilation.6 I place an arterial line first, then induce with small doses of a short-acting agent and rocuronium, never succinylcholine.3 Atropine, phenylephrine and a vasodilator are drawn up, because her swings can be extreme either way. Neurology starts IVIG or plasma exchange. I reassess hemodynamics continuously and plan early tracheostomy if weakness persists.
Pitfalls that cost points
- Trusting quantitative train-of-four in a Guillain-Barré survivor: persistent neuropathy can make it unreliable.3
- Reading a normal SpO2 as adequate ventilation in neuromuscular weakness: hypercapnia comes first, and oxygen hides it.
Rapid-fire
Q: How long do patients with ALS survive? A: Mean 2–4 years from onset, about 1.5 years with early bulbar symptoms; bulbar palsy is present at onset in about 25%.1
Q: What is the classic ALS teaching on neuraxial technique? A: Exacerbations after neuraxial blocks have been reported but are contested; epidural is generally favored over intrathecal.1
Q: What predicts relapse after delivery in MS? A: Disease activity during pregnancy or the year before conception, not the neuraxial technique.5
Q: How often does Guillain-Barré need mechanical ventilation? A: Up to a third in general series; 17% in a 2024 cohort.6
Q: Is sugammadex safe in neuromuscular disease? A: Most reviews consider it safe, but the evidence is limited.2
Numbers to know
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| GBS intubation: vital capacity | <20 mL/kg3 |
| GBS: MIP / MEP | Weaker than 30 / under 40 cmH2O3 |
| GBS dysautonomia | 36% of patients6 |
| GBS ventilated | 17% (up to one third)6 |
| MS neuraxial reports reviewed | 37 reports, 231 patients4 |
| Bulbar onset in ALS | ~25%1 |
Links
- succinylcholine, Neuromuscular blockade, monitoring and reversal, sugammadex, Myasthenia gravis, Muscular dystrophies and myotonias
- Canadian Journal of Anesthesia scoping review of neuromuscular disorders (2022)
Sources
- 1.ALS: anesthetic concerns · OpenAnesthesia · openanesthesia.org
- 2.Mapping the current evidence on the anesthetic management of adult patients with neuromuscular disorders: a scoping review · Canadian Journal of Anesthesia, 2022 · link.springer.comvan den Bersselaar LR, et al. Can J Anesth 2022;69:756-73.
- 3.Guillain-Barré syndrome · NYSORA · nysora.comVentilation thresholds and succinylcholine only; its IVIG dose (mg/kg) is a units error and is not used here.
- 4.Neuraxial anesthesia in patients with multiple sclerosis: a systematic review · Brazilian Journal of Anesthesiology, 2017 · bjan-sba.orgBornemann-Cimenti H, et al. Braz J Anesthesiol 2017;67:404-10. 37 reports, 231 patients.
- 5.Multiple sclerosis · NYSORA · nysora.comCites a 2025 systematic review: 8 studies, 1,315 parturients, no increase in postpartum relapse with neuraxial.
- 6.Clinical predictors for mechanical ventilation assistance in Guillain-Barré syndrome · Frontiers in Neurology, 2024 · frontiersin.orgRodríguez-Méndez AA, et al. Front Neurol 2024;15:1385945. 222 patients.
Facts on this page were checked against these sources on Oct 22, 2026. Guidelines change; confirm doses against current institutional protocols.